Smiling, you were always smiling
How could I have known that you were
Hiding your feelings from me?
I wondered how could it be
Your note there says you don't love me
My worst fear is now reality

You picked a fine time to tell me you don't love me
You picked a fine time to tell me you don't care
And what I thought was love was really just pretending
And your love for me was never really there

Trying, I am always trying
To understand the reason why I'm
Crying, day and night I'm crying
I can't believe I was so blind
It's so clear, it's so clear
That you don't love me
My worst fear
My worst fear is now reality and

You picked a fine time to tell me you don't love me
You picked a fine time to tell me you don't care
And what I thought was love was really just pretending
And your love for me was never really there

How many nights did I sleep alone
Waiting by the phone
I couldn't see what was going on
Told myself our love's still strong
I weighed your trust when times were down
Another love you have found
There's nothing left no more to hide
And there's no easy way to say goodbye

You picked a fine time to tell me you don't love me
You picked a fine time to tell me you don't care
And what I thought was love was really just pretending
And your love for me was never really there