One night you swear to love eternally
Next night youre tellin' me you must be free
You call and whisper sweet things on the phone
I'll call you back to find you're not alone

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
My hearts divided
My loves undecided

If you dont love me you can tell me so
But if you do you have to let her go
Does true commitment scare your heart away
Is indecision just a game you play

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Is it her, is it me

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Which one is it gonna be

I cant put up with what were goin through
So let me tell you what Im gonna do
Im gonna find somebody new and then
When youre around to meeting you again

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
I'll love you like youre lovin me

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
If thats the way it has to be, we'll see

Im gonna keep your love all to myself, baby
While Im also lovin someone else, baby
Im gonna have my cake and eat it too, baby
Just like you... Just like you... Just like you... Just like you

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Is it her, is it me

Our hearts divided
My loves undecided
Which one is it gonna be
It better be me

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Love is made just for two

Our hearts divided
My loves undecided
Just for two, three wont do, thats true

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Is it her, is it me
Is it her or is it me

Our hearts divided
My loves undecided
Which one is it gonna be
It better be me

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
I'll love you like youre lovin me
She cant love you like I do

Our hearts divided
My loves undecided
If thats the way it has to be, we'll see
It better be me

My hearts divided
My loves undecided
Love is made just for two
It just better be me

Our hearts divided
My loves undecided
Just for two, three wont do, thats true
It better be me