I remember passing by your place
I remember looking at a new look on your face
Not feeling welcome here, not feeling great
Not really knowing what I did, or what it takes
To not feel replaced

But it was always you
You moved on, and I did too
And I may not be the best for you
But I'll pray you see
You're the best for me
It was always you

I remember seeing you around
Once or twice here and there in such a small town
I remember seeing you with him
Trying not to let it show that I know I didn't win
Maybe I'll see you again

But it was always you
You moved on, and I did too
And I may not be the best for you
But I'll pray you see
You're the best for me
It was always you

I remember that kiss that you stole
I remember feeling weightless and almost whole
I remember not wanting to let go
The way your eyes stare right through my self control
And I want you to know

But it was always you
You came back, and I did too
And I may not be the best for you
But I'll pray you see
You're the best for me
It was always you

Always you
It was always you
Always you
It was always you