She didn't want my body, she only want my mind
She liked making me feel naughty and she'd treat me so unkind

Lucy wasn't like the stories that I read
I knew that she'd own me once she'd gotten in my head
I'd wait around a little longer just to see her smile
It couldn't hurt to stay a little while

Lucy told me that she looked her best in pictures
Lucy told me that she smiled with her eyes
Lucy tore my heart out, I don't think I'll miss her
I wasn't surprised, Lucy told me lies

She never got my money, it never went that far
Lucy laughed like it was funny when she took away my heart

I realized I couldn't trust a word she said
I knew that she owned me 'cause she'd gotten in my head
I'd wait around a little longer just to see her smile
It couldn't hurt to stay a little while

...I wasn't surprised, I saw it in her eyes, Lucy told me lies