I introduced myself
On a New York street
Where Broadway lights shine bright
And broken hearts meet
It was a September love
We couldn't get enough
Our hearts were falling like
The golden leaves

Now I'm always looking back
On that first snowfall that we had
And that fire burned so fast
And it still does to tell the truth
The whole world's red and green
But I'm just feeling blue
Wonder what it'd be like
To have one Christmas night
With you

We'd slow dance all night long
To Nat King Cole
I'd ask for your leather coat
Pretend it's cold
Instead of a winter wonderland
I'm just winter wondering
What could have been
'Cause all I know

Is that I'm always looking back
On that first snowfall that we had
And that fire burned so fast
And it still does to tell the truth
The whole world's red and green
But I'm just feeling blue
Wonder what it'd be like
To have one Christmas night

Now it's December 24th
And I pour myself one more
Get up the nerve to call
I mean it's Christmas after all

Yeah, the whole world's red and green
But I'm just feeling blue
Wonder what it'd be like
To have one Christmas night
With you