I was a fool to let you in
Knowin' you were playin' with my heart
Thought we were good, I thought we were good
Thought we could make a new start
You let me brokenhearted
From the day your love departed
Boy, this pain can't last
So take me back to when it all seemed so right

When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
Whatcha gonna do about it?

When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
Seemed so right

Boy, you were different when you met
Holdin' my heart, you touched so gently
Now I'm cold inside, so empty
You left me
So now when I wake and you're not there
And I gotta face what I had feared
I do what I want without you, baby
It's crazy

Sittin' reminiscin' 'bout a place in time
You been playin' on my mind
Memories of yesterday
When it all seemed so right

When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
When it all seemed so right (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
Whatcha gonna do about it?

I played the fool for you, baby
But you stole away my heart
I played the fool for you, baby
But you played your part

Sittin' reminiscin' 'bout a place in time
You been playin' on my mind
Memories of yesterday
When it all seemed so right

When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
(Oh-oh-oh)
Seemed so right
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Oh, baby)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Ooh, baby)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Lovin', yeah)
When it all seemed so right (Yeah, yeah, yeah)
Seemed so right (Love)
When it all seemed so right (Yeah)
I was lovin' you (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
When it all seemed so right
Whatcha gonna do about it?